You only have 3 free questions left (including this one).

But it doesn't have to end here! Sign up for the 7-day coding interview crash course and you'll get a free Interview Cake problem every week.

You have a method Rand5() that generates a random integer from 1 to 5. Use it to write a method Rand7() that generates a random integer from 1 to 7.

Rand5() returns each integer with equal probability. Rand7() must also return each integer with equal probability.

Gotchas

Simply running Rand5() twice, adding the results, and taking a modulus won't give us an equal probability for each possible result.

Not convinced? Count the number of ways to get each possible result from 1..71..7.

Your method will have worst-case infinite runtime, because sometimes it will need to "try again."

However, at each "try" you only need to make two calls to Rand5(). If you're making 3 calls, you can do better.

We can get away with worst-case O(1)O(1) space. Does your answer have a non-constant space cost? If you're using recursion (and your language doesn't have tail-call optimization

Some compilers and interpreters will do what's called "tail call optimization" (TCO), where it can optimize some recursive methods to avoid building up a tall call stack. Python and Java decidedly do not use TCO. Some Ruby implementations do, but most don't. Scheme is one of the few languages that guarantee TCO in all implementations. In general, best not to assume your compiler/interpreter will do this work for you.

), you're potentially incurring a worst-case infinite space cost in the call stack.

Overview

The call stack is what a program uses to keep track of method calls. The call stack is made up of stack frames—one for each method call.

For instance, say we called a method that rolled two dice and printed the sum.

  def roll_die():
    return random.randint(1, 6)

def roll_two_and_sum():
    total = 0
    total += roll_die()
    total += roll_die()
    print total

roll_two_and_sum()
We're still translating this code to C#. Here it is in Python 2.7:

First, our program calls RollTwoAndSum(). It goes on the call stack:

RollTwoAndSum()

That function calls RollDie(), which gets pushed on to the top of the call stack:

RollDie()
RollTwoAndSum()

Inside of RollDie(), we call random.randint(). Here's what our call stack looks like then:

random.randint()
RollDie()
RollTwoAndSum()

When random.randint() finishes, we return back to RollDie() by removing ("popping") random.randint()'s stack frame.

RollDie()
RollTwoAndSum()

Same thing when RollDie() returns:

RollTwoAndSum()

We're not done yet! RollTwoAndSum() calls RollDie() again:

RollDie()
RollTwoAndSum()

Which calls random.randint() again:

random.randint()
RollDie()
RollTwoAndSum()

random.randint() returns, then RollDie() returns, putting us back in RollTwoAndSum():

RollTwoAndSum()

Which calls print():

print()
RollTwoAndSum()

What's stored in a stack frame?

What actually goes in a method's stack frame?

A stack frame usually stores:

  • Local variables
  • Arguments passed into the method
  • Information about the caller's stack frame
  • The return address—what the program should do after the function returns (i.e.: where it should "return to"). This is usually somewhere in the middle of the caller's code.

Some of the specifics vary between processor architectures. For instance, AMD64 (64-bit x86) processors pass some arguments in registers and some on the call stack. And, ARM processors (common in phones) store the return address in a special register instead of putting it on the call stack.

The Space Cost of Stack Frames

Each method call creates its own stack frame, taking up space on the call stack. That's important because it can impact the space complexity of an algorithm. Especially when we use recursion.

For example, if we wanted to multiply all the numbers between 11 and nn, we could use this recursive approach:

  public int Product1ToN(int n)
{
    // We assume n >= 1
    return (n > 1) ? (n * Product1ToN(n - 1)) : 1;
}

What would the call stack look like when n = 10?

First, Product1ToN() gets called with n = 10:

    Product1ToN()    n = 10

This calls Product1ToN() with n = 9.

    Product1ToN()    n = 9
    Product1ToN()    n = 10

Which calls Product1ToN() with n = 8.

    Product1ToN()    n = 8
    Product1ToN()    n = 9
    Product1ToN()    n = 10

And so on until we get to n = 1.

    Product1ToN()    n = 1
    Product1ToN()    n = 2
    Product1ToN()    n = 3
    Product1ToN()    n = 4
    Product1ToN()    n = 5
    Product1ToN()    n = 6
    Product1ToN()    n = 7
    Product1ToN()    n = 8
    Product1ToN()    n = 9
    Product1ToN()    n = 10

Look at the size of all those stack frames! The entire call stack takes up O(n)O(n) space. That's right—we have an O(n)O(n) space cost even though our method itself doesn't create any data structures!

What if we'd used an iterative approach instead of a recursive one?

  public int Product1ToN(int n)
{
    // We assume n >= 1
    int result = 1;
    for (int num = 1; num <= n; num++)
    {
        result *= num;
    }

    return result;
}

This version takes a constant amount of space. At the beginning of the loop, the call stack looks like this:

    Product1ToN()    n = 10, result = 1, num = 1

As we iterate through the loop, the local variables change, but we stay in the same stack frame because we don't call any other functions.

    Product1ToN()    n = 10, result = 2, num = 2

    Product1ToN()    n = 10, result = 6, num = 3

    Product1ToN()    n = 10, result = 24, num = 4

In general, even though the compiler or interpreter will take care of managing the call stack for you, it's important to consider the depth of the call stack when analyzing the space complexity of an algorithm.

Be especially careful with recursive functions! They can end up building huge call stacks.

What happens if we run out of space? It's a stack overflow! In C#, the program will just crash and exit.

If the very last thing a method does is call another method, then its stack frame might not be needed any more. The method could free up its stack frame before doing its final call, saving space.

This is called tail call optimization (TCO). If a recursive function is optimized with TCO, then it may not end up with a big call stack.

In general, most languages don't provide TCO. Scheme is one of the few languages that guarantee tail call optimization. Some Ruby, C, and Javascript implementations may do it. Python and Java decidedly don't.

Breakdown

Start your free trial!

Log in or sign up with one click to get immediate access to 3 free mock interview questions

Where do I enter my password?

Actually, we don't support password-based login. Never have. Just the OAuth methods above. Why?

  1. It's easy and quick. No "reset password" flow. No password to forget.
  2. It lets us avoid storing passwords that hackers could access and use to try to log into our users' email or bank accounts.
  3. It makes it harder for one person to share a paid Interview Cake account with multiple people.

Solution

Start your free trial!

Log in or sign up with one click to get immediate access to 3 free mock interview questions

Where do I enter my password?

Actually, we don't support password-based login. Never have. Just the OAuth methods above. Why?

  1. It's easy and quick. No "reset password" flow. No password to forget.
  2. It lets us avoid storing passwords that hackers could access and use to try to log into our users' email or bank accounts.
  3. It makes it harder for one person to share a paid Interview Cake account with multiple people.

Complexity

Worst-case O()O(\infty) time (we might keep re-rolling forever) and O(1)O(1) space.

What We Learned

Start your free trial!

Log in or sign up with one click to get immediate access to 3 free mock interview questions

Where do I enter my password?

Actually, we don't support password-based login. Never have. Just the OAuth methods above. Why?

  1. It's easy and quick. No "reset password" flow. No password to forget.
  2. It lets us avoid storing passwords that hackers could access and use to try to log into our users' email or bank accounts.
  3. It makes it harder for one person to share a paid Interview Cake account with multiple people.

Do you have an answer?

10
11
12
# Implement rand7() using rand5()
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Reset editor

Powered by qualified.io

. . .